One thought on “The Translator”

1. My husband is a huge John Crowley fan, and one day, he very un subtly left The Translator on my nightstand I admit I was a little hesitant I enjoyed Crowley s other works, but I also found him hard work to get through But The Translator turned out to be very different from Little, Big or the Aegypt cycle The prose is still gorgeous, but this time, it s fluid and almost cinematic as opposed to convoluted and dream like Crowley went very far from magical realism and dove straight into historical f [...]

   Reply

---

2. I really enjoyed this book It focuses on the relationship between a dissident Russia poet who is a professor at a midwestern college and his student, a female undergrad who helps him translate his work from Russian to English one summer It is also a study of the early 1960 s in America During the course of the novel the Cold War is on, America is getting involved covertly in Viet Nam, the Cuban Missile Crisis takes place, and JFK is assassinated These events are an integral part of the story The [...]

   Reply

---

3. I like to think that John Crowley is always a treat Sure, I ve only read two of his novels, but they have been so good as to allow me to call myself a John Crowley fan The other book of his that I have read, Little, Big is often considered his masterpiece It is unsurprising, then, that I will compare The Translator with it.The Translator is a much simpler story than Little, Big It is much grounded in reality though not entirely, and the plot is not nearly as complex This does not effect one of [...]

   Reply

---

4. A being such as that couldn t die all in a day and be gone, it would take far longer, wouldn t it There would be things he would have to do, to tell us We, the rest of us, can t turn back after we have turned to go, but surely he could, for a time Oh turn back, she thought, turn back, make this not to have happened all in a day forever This is true the novels of John Crowley are like a garden in my heart If you return, O my dead, and you will, from your ashes and earth,Return if you can as the g [...]

   Reply

---

5. Beautiful Wonderful I tried to slow down my reading of it at the end, because I didn t want for the book to be over But the ending was amazing, filling, the world made whole The language was strong throughout, at times peaking into gorgeous, lush descriptions He held her a long time, kissed her cheek and her cool brow, her mouth, her tears She knew she knew by now that there really can be a person, one at least, that you can embrace as easily and wholly as though the two of you were one thing, a [...]

   Reply

---

6. I was captivated by this book It is the story of a girl, Kit, who is disconnected from her peers and life At college she becomes involved with a Russian expatriate poet, also disconnected from his life, and works with him to translate his poems The story moves back and forth from Kit s childhood to her college years to a much later period when she attends a conference in Russia honoring the poet The time frame of the early 1960 s and the Cuban missile crisis almost overwhelms the beautiful story [...]

   Reply

---

7. Ah, such a relief so few 5 star books encountered so far this year Is this Crowley s masterpiece I loved Little, Big, but this seems better mastered to me Also a great book to discover or rediscover for Our Times, such as they are You ve got McCarthyism at its height You ve got national panic over the Russians, over the threat of missiles coming at any moment, apparently even worse than what we kids felt in the 70s THESE kids had grown up with duck and cover drills, largely abandoned by the time [...]

   Reply

---

8. Hard for me to believe the ending could a poet ever really be that important, politically, in terms of the Cuban missile crisis but worth it for 1 that ever bravura ability of the fiction writer to include decent poems in her his novel really we should make a shortlist Pale Fire, The Anthologist, Possession and 2 various swoony love passages like this one It seemed to her that they spent a very long time there together not hours but days, years even, the whole course of a long deep love affair t [...]

   Reply

---

9. Christa Malone the translator of this tale falls in love with an emmigreSoviet poet who has lost everything But under what circumstances has he made it to the United States The story and Christa s own poetry emerges slowly This is a haunting tale about life in the Soviet bloc that most of us can never fully appreciate We come very close to understanding as we see the Russian poet s old work brought home But it is also a tale of the venality and narrow mindedness of the 60s I came away wanting to [...]

   Reply

---

10. A complex book in which I especially loved the poetry and talk about poetry language and the way personal and shared histories intertwined, the way mysteries remained mysterious and the main characters, Kyt and Innokenti Good read.

    Reply

---

11. In the interests of full disclosure, I hold Little, Big and to a slightly lesser extent Engine Summer in such high esteem that Crowley could probably publish a book consisting of nothing but his grocery lists, or just a book of blank pages, and I d still give it the highest rating allowed He s the rare writer that can combine a vivid imagination for the fantastic with absolutely matchless prose, able to ground us in the ephemeral while still making it seem like a dispatch from a world that only [...]

    Reply

---

12. I thoroughly enjoyed this book If you re a writer and or translator, it s a book to savor.

    Reply

---

13. I wanted to love this book than I did It was not a bad book, and I thought the character development was fairly good But the book as a whole left me wanting something, or perhaps just feeling like I missed something somewhere The writing was a bit tedious at times, and I found myself skimming and skipping ahead in paragraphs, something I try not to do I also am admittedly not nearly the fan of poetry as the characters, and I grew a bit weary of reading the chunks of poetry placed throughout It [...]

    Reply

---

14. This is one of those books that just do not sit well with me This book did not cause mixed emotions or even flickering enjoyment No, this book was not for me by page 2 I love books based on and in Russia, which is why I picked this book up 6 years ago and thought for sure I would enjoy it Well that was before I meticulously researched books and authors, had I done so then I would not own this book Why did I not like it Let me explain.The writing style in this book can only be described as flower [...]

    Reply

---

15. There are few feelings better than that of picking up a dollar paperback at some little bookstore, only to crack it open months later with some trepidation and discover something astonishing This was one of those books for me It s the story of a Russian poet and his American translator during the Cuban missile crisis, but that seems a pathetically simple explanation for what the book is actually ABOUT For anyone who has ever been forced to analyze poetry within an inch of its life, this book doe [...]

    Reply

---

16. Christa Kit Malone is an aspiring poet in the early 60s The first half of this novel records the sad losses and mistakes of her teenage years, and her visit decades later to post communist Russia, where, as a now successful poet, she attends a conference on the deceased Russian emigr poet, Innokenti Falin.The second half depicts her first turbulent summer at a Mid West university, where the said Falin, recently exiled, is teaching poetry An intense relationship develops between them, built aroun [...]

    Reply

---

17. A naive, but somehow still mature college student in 1961 has a close relationship with an exiled Soviet poet who is her professor This is an interesting story in an interesting era fraught with US Soviet tension The writing is quite beautiful and the writer uses a deliberate, effective sort of non punctuation in his dialogue which I like a lot Also what it says about translation and understanding and clarity or not Who here is the translator Who makes clear for whom Who really understands the o [...]

    Reply

---

18. I liked this book It s the story of a relationship between a Russian exiled poet named Falin and one of his American students, a young woman named Kit, during the early 1960s, just as the Cuban missile crisis hits Kit helps Falin translate some of his poems into English The seemingly simple story is anything but Among other things, it serves as a footnote to the translations and fills us in on historical contexts Russian and American , the relevant parts of Kit s and Falin s personal backgrounds [...]

    Reply

---

19. This novel takes us to the Midwest during the buildup to the Cuban Missile Crisis An exiled Russian poet, modeled on Joseph Brodsky, is offered a teaching position at a midwestern university His poetry seminar is really only for upperclassmen, and only within the department But a young woman with a troubled past, a freshman, is admitted to the course, and through her encounters with the poet both their lives are changed.Though when she met him she knew no Russian at all, she ends up translating [...]

    Reply

---

20. For me, if an author has than one book out and half way through the book I am reading, I think when I am finished with this one, I totally want to read something else he she has written then I know the book really is that good.I felt that on page 10 I am not sure what exactly hooked me, but I was engaged with this book start to finish There is something beautiful about weaving a coming of age love story into a novel set during turbulent times I know this is not the first time that method has be [...]

    Reply

---

21. A beautiful book Sad in many places, but neither pathetic or tragic Eleagic, maybe The protagonist suffers three or four great losses, but these loses aren t just some stuff that happens pathetic , nor are they unavoidably impossible situations tragic Instead, these losses are transformed into something else It s not sacrifice or redemption, where the losses serve some greater good or purpose this, I think, would cheapen or demean them here Instead, they are I don t know transformed maybe, into [...]

    Reply

---

22. I normally really love his books, but this one, while I enjoyed it, didn t totally come together for me The mid century, midwestern university setting and the feeling of nuclear dread were terrific And gigantic props for including a romance between a male professor and a female student that was completely non creepy, totally from her POV, and didn t smack remotely of wish fulfillment or projection It s one of the few books that I think would have worked better for me if it was longer I feel as i [...]

    Reply

---

23. This novel was passed along to me by a friend after I mentioned that I was interested in translation It is about a love affair between a young college student and a famous Russian poet during the Cold War Not so much about what it means to translate poetry in an academic sense , it is a story about politics, gender politics, poetry, and coming of age Crowly s writing is quite lyrical and pretty, and for a male author he conjures up a female protagonist who is impressively real and sympathetic It [...]

    Reply

---

24. This is one of my favorite novels It s about a young girl going to college during a very tense time between Russia and America She meets and falls for a Russian professor of poetry, and begins learning Russian The relationship between them is complicated and her past is not exactly simple, while he remains relatively mysterious and almost in shadow for most of the book.This is a novel that jumps between past and present easily, and doesn t leave you confused as to what happened when There are a [...]

    Reply

---

25. I enjoyed Kit and Falin s stories and the story of Falin and Kit They were wisps in each others lives but I think that reflected the poetry they both connected with This novel never became too historical and when it did it was on a personal level, giving insight into Falin s character However, there were a few moments I felt a little irritated to have to read through war commentary I was at the beach for Christ s sake When I was finally done, I loved closing the book and thinking on the mysteri [...]

    Reply

---

26. hmmmere were things I liked about this book interesting characters for example but overall I found it too vague and mysterious The whole time I read it I was waiting for the author to give clues as to what the heck was going on and he never did he kept it so vague that it was hard to even think of your own scenarios of what really happened because you didn t have enough information for that You never got that satisfied feeling of either guessing right or guessing wrong and being shocked but sat [...]

    Reply

---

27. I thought this would be a nice contrast to my Cuban book, but the Cuban missile crisis was merely another thread in a complicated story The language is beautiful, the poetry comprehensible, the characters mysterious The plot drew me in, again a book that you have to drag yourself away from But the end I certainly would like to know just where Falin went and why, rather than the mystical lesser angel explanation Next I m reading a non fiction account of a Palestinian diplomat, driven by a need fo [...]

    Reply

---

28. This was a good book The only reason for only 3 stars may be a reader fault rather than a writer fault Perhaps I did not give it the care and attention it deserved life has been hectic that s my excuse I read this because I would like to read Little,Big and they didn t have it at the branch I usually go to, but I thought I d give this a go at least initially I really enjoyed the story telling Cuban Missile Crisis climax and I connected with the artist in the poet girl I am looking forward to rea [...]

    Reply

---

29. Oh excellent I loved my time with this bookOthers have reviewed and or commented eloquently I concurjust select one to your taste I can add that for those four reviews, it is ALL true in my opinion.Quoting from the review from the NYT Book Review at the back of the novel The book gives us a world so suffused with beauty that its inhabitants manage to speak in fragments of poetryCrowley s subject matter is grand and serious, involving nothing less than the souls of nations and the transforming po [...]

    Reply

---

30. Told during the 1960s with the Cuban Missile Crisis as a backdrop, John Crowley has created a smart love story in The Translator The story follows Christa, a college student who develops a relationship with one of her instructors, Falin, a Russian poet who has been exiled from his country under mysterious circumstances Much like the translations that Christa is making for Falin of his poems, their relationship is complicated and intricate John Crowley s prose is beautifully written and the story [...]

    Reply

---