One thought on “The Forgotten Soldier”

1. The best War Memoir I ve ever read Heart breaking, brutal, real, lyrical, depressing, insightful, and in some ways familiar I simply loved this book Guy Sajer tells his story as a young half french, half german boy joining the Wermacht in 1942 His story spans his journey from Germany to Poland for training in the transportation Corps and then to the east in the winter of 42 to resupply the German Army at the Don river Later he joins the Gross Deutschland division as an infantryman in order to qu [...]

   Reply

---

2. Writers like Sajer, will never allow the future generations to forget, the miseries of world war soldiers.World war two was fought by soldiers but described by soldiers cum writers Sajer belong to this rare breed he accomplished this rare job by writing, under stressful circumstances and arranging the information, for future readers.Sajer did a fine job in describing, the situation and psychology of a foot soldier, respect and value of enemy, Morality of a losing infantry, Hate for partisans, Ag [...]

   Reply

---

3. Guy Sajer s account of life on the Eastern Front in World War II is a must read If All Quiet on the Western Front left any mark upon you at all, this book will floor you You will fully understand the brutality of war, the brutality of the Soviets and the Nazis You will fully understand the brutal nature of total war and fierce nature of mankind who stoked and fed the machinations of World War.He s just a dumb kid in the beginning He s an old man at the end You ll never put up with jingoistic non [...]

   Reply

---

4. There is no such thing as a just war The concept of just war is something theologians like Augustine or Thomas Aquinas or academics argue When it comes to real war and actual fighting theologians and academics are as useless as tits on a boar hog Killing others and being killed is humankind at its most primitive Fighting a war is deadly serious Discipline, courage and a will to win are critical to success in war Finding the guts to kill or be killed and to endure almost unbelievable hardship in [...]

   Reply

---

5. Through the eyes of Guy Sajer, I have rediscovered the putrid horror of war and the interminable depth of the human soul Such a juxtaposition concerns me In the flowing filth of destruction, can one glimpse the shimmer of the human quality So many people allude to war as the pinnacle of evil within human nature Undoubtedly, the mystifying magnitude of our destructive tendencies overwhelms our vision and guides us into stereotypical cognition of ideological evil and discontent However, does this [...]

   Reply

---

6. Stalingrad is lost and the German Army is no longer the formidable force which swept through Europe at the start of the war In retreat, they are chased and hunted by the much larger Red Army.Sajer is a seventeen year old German soldier struggling to survive the onslaught from the Russian Army Facing starvation,daily fear of enemy bombardment, disease, exhaustion,and the unforgiving Russian winter, Sajer s experiences are retold with chilling detail and brutal honesty Too many people learn about [...]

   Reply

---

7. Amazing, shocking, and unforgettable.This is the best book about WWII that you can find.Forget the U.S involvement, or the British, or the French.Hell, I m Canadian, but I always knew the real battle was in the East against the huge tank divisions of Germany and those of Russia.And yet here is the infantryman s perspective.And not even a German, but a French man.Or boy, since Sajer was 17 when he was drafted in.And what did he see Everything The Eastern front in all it s horrible form.This is a [...]

   Reply

---

8. Guy Sajer was a sixteen year old boy in 1942 who was brought up in France by a French father and a German mother After being drafted into the German army transport division he was sent to the Russian Front He later volunteered to join a crack combat division called the Grosse Deutschland This book describes his personal account of the two years he spent fighting on the Russian Front He takes us on a journey through two brutal Russian winters, being bombarded by artillery, taking part in battles [...]

   Reply

---

9. The Forgotten Soldier was first published in 1965, and concerns events that happened over 20 years previously, when the author was a teenager living in France who was drafted into the German army The memoir has since become the subject of much criticism by historians who question much of the historical detail, especially with regards to troop movements and dates Supporters of the work argue that historical facts of strategic troop movements can be found elsewhere, and that the strength of this p [...]

   Reply

---

10. This is a very powerful book it s not for the squeamish The author was a teenager who enlisted in the German army in 1942, and following basic training, was sent to the Eastern front as a truck driver In 1943 he volunteered to become an infantryman in the elite Gross Deutchland division in exchange for a one week leave in Germany He went to Berlin but found life there little different from the war zone in the Ukraine daily bombing from the American Air Corps and little food.Sajer returned to the [...]

    Reply

---

11. I read a review of this book around 1971 and my Dad and I eagerly awaited its arrival at the library We both thought it was a great read It was one of the first popular from the German point of view stories available The genre has grown quite a bit since then.Twenty years later in the early 90s, there was and perhaps still is a controversy over whether the author is telling his story or one that is, shall we say, a composite.The debate is available, just search the web, I ve ready the book 2 or [...]

    Reply

---

12. The author s experience was so grueling, and his telling of it so eloquent, that I felt drained when I finished reading this to pick one detail that sums it up, he ends the book this isn t a spoiler, since you know he had to survive to write it by describing how when he finally got home after the war and walked up to his family s home, his mother didn t recognize the worn out old man greeting her as the boy who had left home for the army a few years earlier.

    Reply

---

13. Where to start This book has affected me greatly I did expect to be shocked, and did expect to read an account of some appalling experiences of a soldier fighting in the heart of an horrendously bloody and grisly conflict But nothing could really prepare the reader for the overwhelming relentlessness of it all This is a reading experience that should not be at all taken lightly.Guy Sajer was a very young Alsatian barely seventeen I think , of mixed Franco German parentage, who finds himself in t [...]

    Reply

---

14. in is international These words are the central thrust of a book that asks you to pity the German soldier on the Eastern Front of World War II It is not easy for many, considering the crimes committed, and for the well informed Sajer does not make it much easier He believes in the anti communist part of the cause, which is understandable Yet he is morally deaf to the carnage wrought by the Nazis He even at one point has a good thing to say about Adolf Hitler.Yet, pain is international, and the [...]

    Reply

---

15. I read Sajer s story 20 years ago and I was deeply impressed by it He was among those Alsatians who joined the Wehrmacht following the incorporation of Alsace one of France s eastern regions into the Third Reich following France s defeat in June 1940 Sajer himself is of French and German parentage Since the time I read this book, questions have been raised as to its authenticity Be that as it may, Sajer s descriptions of serving both with an anti partisan and later with an elite infantry unit on [...]

    Reply

---

16. The war seemed to have turned me into a monster of indifference, a man witout feelings I was still three months short of eighteen, but felt at least thirty five Now that I have reaches that age, I know better Peace has brought me many pleasures, but nothing as powerful as the passion for surviving in wartime, that faith in love, and that sense of absolutes It often strikes me with horror that peace is really extremely monotonous During the terrible moments of war one longs for peace with a passi [...]

    Reply

---

17. An amazing read, a truly horrifying account of World War 2 and how it was experienced by the soldiers It is a very long and detailed personal account of a French German soldier, giving gory details as well as very personal and honest accounts of what went on.Very moving, thoughtful and intellegent, and very very sad.

    Reply

---

18. A descent into hell as we read about an ethnic German from France who joins the Wehrmacht in 1943 and is promptly sent to the Eastern Front Talk about bad timing Things quickly go from bad to worse as you follow him retreating back to Fatherland with the broken remnants of the Master Race Hard to feel sorry for any of the Krauts in WWII, but this is as close as you will get Great book.

    Reply

---

19. I enjoyed this book even though I had read some criticism Sure there may be some areas that the author has muddled, but has also been implied he may have a bit to hide With all that in mind this is still a read about a brutal time for a young man For those that are considering reading this be warned though, it is long and the action is non stop.

    Reply

---

20. Meh Honestly, I could probably have given this two stars but I think that my harsh criticism is at least in part due to the fact that I m outgrowing the point in my life where military biographies will do it for me and I think that had this been my cup of tea recently I would have rated it at least 4 stars So I ll split the difference.The best part of this book for me at this stage in my life was hearing the similarities between an average German soldier in WW2 and knowing how close his story w [...]

    Reply

---

21. Brilliant account of the Eastern FrontThis is one of most gut wrenching first hand accounts of the Eastern Front I ve read Mr Sager does than an excellent job in describing the brutality and hopelessness he and his Komrades endured in Russia He puts the reader with his squad, feeling and seeing everything they are enduring His description of driving a convoy from Kharkov to the trapped Sixth Army at Stalingrad sets the tempo of this work Who would think being a convoy driver could be so brutal [...]

    Reply

---

22. I read this book while enduring Officer Candidate School If you want to read a story about what war is really like, then read this book The author lived it and he does a very good job of reliving it for you through his writing It s not the normal story about WWII that you see here in the US Mr Sajer is in the German army and spends a good deal of time on the eastern front The descriptions are vivid, the fear is palpable.Mr Sajer basically says in the book that you cannot appreciate just how mise [...]

    Reply

---

23. It s good, not great Needed an editor much too long Endlessly repetitive yet often psychologically dissociative And far to many references to I think the town was named such and such could have made of an effort to uncover the German or current Russian names But, nonetheless, an impressive recounting of the horrors of the Russian front from an infantry perspective __The most interesting aspect of the book spoiler alert is the toward the end he fought his way to Kiel, where he was taken prisoner [...]

    Reply

---

24. 10 STARS The real brutal tragedy of the german soldier who has to fight on the eastern front with its bombings, battles, frost bites, starvation, retreats all experienced by a half french, half german Sajer.As with every book of this kind everyone would tend to be a little skeptic that the actions portrayed actually took place After research i will say there is just so much evidence pointing to Sajer being authentic and so little evidence pointing to him being a fraud that I will conclude that h [...]

    Reply

---

25. A unique hardhitting memoir of War on the Eastern front.No other book covers the sheer savagery of war between Germany and Russia as this book does The author Guy Sajer fought with the Grossdeustchland division of the German Army against the Russians and witnessed the horrors first hand The hunger, sleeplessness, cold, depravity, tiredness and constant stuggle for survival take their toll on the soldier who is hardly out of his teens.For anyone seeking the prespective of a common German soldier, [...]

    Reply

---

26. The Forgotten Soldier, has been called, All Quiet on the Western Front of World War II It is that, both and less More Guy Sajer has written a volume twice the length of, All Quiet It is a story autobiography largely untold of the experiences of German soldiers on the Russian front battling the Red Army and the Russian winter Sajer s account compels close, deep interest It is a most worthy effort but Sajer does not have the literary skills of Erich Remarque I read somewhere I cannot recall where [...]

    Reply

---

27. just started and it s starting slow, just spotted a forest of Russian soldiers crawling like ants on a mound north and south, while we go west to east but I loved all quiet on the western front and I love History on any fronts except American History Off to Ukraine Finally finished this Ww2 memoir very good, by far the best book I read on ww2, very sad read I think the part I found the most curious was how he described how the U.S soldiers treated him toward the end of the book Brave Man 4.5 5

    Reply

---

28. The forgotten soldier is a history of a young soldier, all emotions, all fears, one book of one s man survival, the brutal cold He tell us about training, his first combat, every he feels on the western front, an no political history, only a personal history, the point of view of infantery soldier of the most devastating conflict I think is highly recommended if you like memories about the war.

    Reply

---

29. There is a lot to take away from these memoirs of the most terrible conflict in human history Gives you some perspective on your own life Those who haven t lived through the experience may sympathize as they read, the way one sympathizes with the hero of a novel or a play, but they certainly will never understand, as one cannot understand the unexplainable.

    Reply

---

30. This book was an eye opener about the plight of the German foot soldier on the Eastern front in WWII There was an unbelievable amount of suffering It really amazed me that Sajer was able to survive some of the situations that he was in Not just the fighting, but the cold and hunger are very real worries You get inside Sajer s head and learn about hardships and fear a soldier on the losing side faces He doesn t hold anything back well there are a couple of incidents that he writes about that he s [...]

    Reply

---